2021 Salsa
Horsethief Carbon XTR
$7,498
Suspension
Wheels
Drivetrain
Brakes
Request confirmed!
We will check if your bike is available at a bike shop near you.
You will be contacted by email to confirm the date and time as well as the bike shop for your test ride.
Expert Review, Specs & Price
Expert Review
Salsa went hard on stability and refinement here. The 29" carbon wheels with 64mm rubber skid over chunky roots and keep you planted at speed, while the carbon frame feels taut under power and during punchy moves. XTR mechanical shifting gives precise, familiar gear changes and the twin 180mm rotors bring predictable stopping on steep sections. Riders who climb to descend and want a confident, fast-rolling all-rounder will like this bike, but if you crave the flickiest handling or prefer electronic shifting, you trade a bit of playfulness and wireless simplicity here.
Pros
- 29" carbon wheels roll over chunk and maintain momentum on rough terrain
- 64mm tire width increases grip and confidence on fast, loose descents
- Carbon frame stays stiff under sprinting and technical efforts, so power goes to the ground
- Mechanical XTR shifting is tactile and familiar for riders who prefer cable-actuated setups
- 180mm front and rear rotors give strong, controllable braking on long descents
Cons
- 64mm tires make the bike less flickable in tight, techy switchbacks
- Mechanical shifting means you miss the convenience of an electronic setup for remote tuning and lighter lever feel
Best for :
- Riders who climb to descend and want a stable, confidence-inspiring machine
- All-day rides that mix fast singletrack with rough fire roads
- Fast trail riders who value momentum and braking consistency
- Riders who prefer tactile, mechanical shifting over electronic systems
Not for :
- Riders seeking an ultra-nimble, playful bike for tight tech trails
Best used Mountain bike deals
Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping
Best cheaper alternatives
At a glance
Terrain
This Salsa trail bike is average when it comes to technical terrain. It is better suited to technical terrain than 52% of the models in its category and more focused on flowing trails than 44%.
Best used Mountain bike deals
Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping
Full specifications
Fork
Rear Suspension
Drivetrain
Braking
Wheels
Components
Technology
Cyclist reviews
Ratings and comments from owners.
10 seconds of your time help thousands of cyclists.
Support Independent Cycling Expertise
Help us remain a free and unbiased service. By sharing with your network, you help thousands of cyclists.
Thank you for your support!
Improve the comparator
Your feedback helps the community 🚲