2021 Salsa
Horsethief Carbon XT
$5,699
Suspension
Wheels
Drivetrain
Brakes
Request confirmed!
We will check if your bike is available at a bike shop near you.
You will be contacted by email to confirm the date and time as well as the bike shop for your test ride.
Expert Review, Specs & Price
Expert Review
Salsa leaned into stability here. The 29" wheels and 64mm rubber roll over chunk and keep the front end planted on rough lines, while the carbon frame feels composed when you pick up speed. The mechanical XT groupset shifts cleanly and the hydraulic discs with 180mm rotors give consistent bite on long descents. But the setup is more about controlled, all-day confidence than ultra-quick flickability, so riders who want a single bike for varied climbs and rowdy descents will like it, though you'll trade a bit of pop and playful nimbleness for that planted feel.
Pros
- 29" wheels plus 64mm tires roll confidently over rocks and roots, helping maintain momentum on technical trails
- Carbon frame keeps the chassis composed at speed and soaks chop without feeling vague
- Shimano XT mechanical shifting is reliable and predictable on long rides
- Hydraulic discs with 180mm rotors give steady braking power and modulation on sustained descents
Cons
- Aluminium wheels add some rotational weight compared with lighter options, which you notice on long, steep climbs
- Setup leans toward planted stability, so it's less flickable and playful in tight, BMX-like moves
Best for :
- All-day riders who climb to descend and want a stable, confidence-inspiring ride
- Those who tackle mixed terrain from flow trails to technical singletrack
- Riders who value reliable shifting and strong hydraulic braking on long rides
Not for :
- Riders chasing a highly playful, poppy bike for jump lines and tight pump tracks
Best used Mountain bike deals
Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping
Best cheaper alternatives
At a glance
Terrain
This Salsa trail bike is average when it comes to technical terrain. It is better suited to technical terrain than 52% of the models in its category and more focused on flowing trails than 44%.
Best used Mountain bike deals
Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping
Full specifications
Fork
Rear Suspension
Drivetrain
Braking
Wheels
Components
Technology
Cyclist reviews
Ratings and comments from owners.
10 seconds of your time help thousands of cyclists.
Support Independent Cycling Expertise
Help us remain a free and unbiased service. By sharing with your network, you help thousands of cyclists.
Thank you for your support!
Improve the comparator
Your feedback helps the community 🚲