Compare the Best Bikes
Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.
Shimano
Tiagra
Shimano
Tiagra
Shimano
105
Bontrager
R1 Hard-Case Lite
Rear: 700" - Tube
Rear: 700"
Trek
Trek
Summary!
These two Trek Domane models share an upright, comfort-oriented riding position, 700c wheels, 32c tires and hydraulic disc brakes, making this a true endurance bike comparison focused on long rides. Both keep a rigid seatpost and similar wheel and tire sizing for stable, predictable handling.
The most noticeable differences are frame material and weight: the AL 4 uses aluminum at 10.35 kg while the SL 5 has a carbon frame and weighs 9.02 kg, a clear weight gap that affects climbing and acceleration. The AL 4 runs a Tiagra 2×10 groupset, while the SL 5 uses a 105 2×12 drivetrain, which changes gear range and shifting refinement.
Choose the SL 5 if a lighter carbon frame and a 105 2×12 drivetrain matter for longer rides and quicker efforts. Stick with the AL 4 if you prefer the aluminum option with the Tiagra 2×10 setup while keeping the same upright comfort.
Best used Road bike deals
Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping
Popular comparisons
The most viewed comparisons around this bike