Compare the Best Bikes
Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.
Shimano
R8170
Shimano
CL800
Shimano
Ultegra, Ultegra Di2
Shimano
Ultegra, Ultegra Di2
S-Works
Turbo
Rear: 700"
Pirelli
P Zero Race
Rear: 700" - Tubeless Ready
Specialized
SL8
Trek
Summary!
These are two race-oriented carbon road bikes that share Ultegra/Ultegra Di2 drivetrains, hydraulic disc brakes, 700c wheels, rigid seatposts, and a sporty riding position. That common kit makes this a head-to-head comparison of small but meaningful details.
The most tangible differences are weight and tire width: the Tarmac lists 7.16 kg while the Madone is 7.31 kg, and the Tarmac runs 26c tires versus 28c on the Madone; both accept up to 32c clearance. With identical gearing (2×12) and similar hardware, those weight and tire choices will shape climbing feel, rolling resistance, and cornering confidence.
Choose the Tarmac if a lighter, snappier climb and slightly narrower rubber suit your racing style. Opt for the Madone if a bit more tire volume aligns with your handling or comfort preferences.
Popular comparisons
The most viewed comparisons around this bike