Compare the Best Bikes
Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.
RockShox
Judy Silver TK Solo Air
RockShox
Recon Gold RL
Shimano
MT200
Shimano
MT4100
Sram
NX Eagle, SX Eagle
Shimano
XT, SLX
Schwalbe
Smart Sam
Rear: 29"
Bontrager
Sainte-Anne Pro XR
Rear: 29" - TLR
Scott
Scale Carbon HMF
Trek
Summary!
This head-to-head compares two 29er XC bikes that share 1x12 drivetrains, RockShox forks and hydraulic disc brakes. Both target fast, efficient riding with similar wheel size and drivetrain layout, making this a focused comparison for racers and marathon riders.
Key differences shape the riding experience: the Scott lists at 12.7 kg with a carbon frame and 100mm fork travel, while the Trek is slightly lighter at 12.48 kg with an aluminum frame and 120mm fork travel. Tire widths differ too—Scott at 2.35" versus Trek at 2.2"—and the Scott uses a rigid seatpost where the Trek has a dropper. Groupsets contrast between NX/SX Eagle and Shimano XT/SLX.
Choose the Scott if carbon and wider tires are priorities; pick the Trek if slightly lower weight, longer fork travel and a dropper seatpost suit your XC objectives.
Popular comparisons
The most viewed comparisons around this bike