Black Friday:the best bike deals
Home All bikes Bike comparison : Tallboy S / Carbon C Santa Cruz 2024 vs Top Fuel 9.8 XT Gen 4 Trek 2025
Advertisement

Compare the Best Bikes

Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.

PRICE
OPTISCORE
CATEGORY
WEIGHT
TYPE
FORK
REAR SUSPENSION
BRAKES
GROUPSET
WHEELS
FRAME
POWER METER
SEATPOST
Price
OptiScore
7/10
Category
Trail
Weight
13.56 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Fork

FOX

34 Float Performance

Travel: 130mm
Rear Suspension

FOX

Float Performance

Travel: 120mm
Brakes

SRAM

G2 R

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Sram

GX Eagle

1 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 32 · 10-50
Wheels

Maxxis

Forekaster

Front: 29"
Rear: 29"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Santa Cruz

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Dropper
Price
OptiScore
7.9/10
Category
Trail
Weight
13.45 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Fork

RockShox

Pike Select+

Travel: 130mm
Rear Suspension

RockShox

Deluxe Ultimate RCT

Travel: 120mm
Brakes

Shimano

XT M8120

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Shimano

XT

1 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 30 · 10-51
Wheels

Bontrager

Gunnison RSL XT

Front: 27.5" - Tubeless Ready
Rear: 29" - Tubeless Ready
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Dropper
Price
OptiScore
7/10
7.9/10
Category
Trail
Trail
Weight
13.56 kg
13.45 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Carbon
Fork

FOX

34 Float Performance

Travel: 130mm

RockShox

Pike Select+

Travel: 130mm
Rear Suspension

FOX

Float Performance

Travel: 120mm

RockShox

Deluxe Ultimate RCT

Travel: 120mm
Brakes

SRAM

G2 R

Type: Hydraulic Disc

Shimano

XT M8120

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Sram

GX Eagle

1 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 32 · 10-50

Shimano

XT

1 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 30 · 10-51
Wheels

Maxxis

Forekaster

Front: 29"
Rear: 29"
Type: Aluminum

Bontrager

Gunnison RSL XT

Front: 27.5" - Tubeless Ready
Rear: 29" - Tubeless Ready
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Santa Cruz

Type: Carbon

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
None
Seatpost
Dropper
Dropper

Summary!

This comparison puts two carbon trail bikes with 130mm front and 120mm rear travel head to head. Both run 1x12 drivetrains, hydraulic disc brakes, 2.4" tires with 2.5" clearance, and dropper posts, making them close on spec sheet basics.

Key differences shape the riding feel: the Tallboy S rides on 29" wheels while the Top Fuel uses 27.5", altering momentum and maneuverability. Component brands diverge too — Fox front and rear on the Tallboy versus RockShox on the Trek — and the Santa Cruz lists a marginally higher weight (13.56 kg vs 13.45 kg), affecting climb and playfulness.

Choose the Tallboy if you prefer the roll-over ability of 29ers and Fox suspension. Opt for the Top Fuel if the slightly lighter package and 27.5" agility suit your trail style.


Popular comparisons

The most viewed comparisons around this bike


Similar bikes

Interesting alternatives to discover

At a glance

Compare key features at a glance

Santa Cruz Tallboy S / Carbon C
Trek Top Fuel 9.8 XT Gen 4
Avg. Trail

Weight

Avg. Trail : 13.7 kg

Light Heavy
Avg. Trail
13.6 kg
13.5 kg

Terrain

Avg. Trail : Mixed

Smooth pavement Cobbles / Rough
Avg. Trail
Santa Cruz Tallboy S / Carbon C
Trek Top Fuel 9.8 XT Gen 4

Support Independent Cycling Expertise

Help us remain a free and unbiased service. By sharing with your network, you help thousands of cyclists.

Thank you for your support!