Black Friday:the best bike deals
Home All bikes Bike comparison : Propel Advanced 1 Giant 2025 vs Madone SL 5 Gen 8 Trek 2027
Advertisement

Compare the Best Bikes

Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.

PRICE
OPTISCORE
CATEGORY
WEIGHT
TYPE
BRAKES
GROUPSET
WHEELS
FRAME
POWER METER
SEATPOST
Price
OptiScore
6/10
Category
Aero
Weight
8.42 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Brakes

Shimano

105 Di2

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Shimano

105 Di2

2 × 12 Electronic
Gearing: 52/36 · 11-34
Wheels

Giant

Gavia Course 1

Front: 700" - Tubeless
Rear: 700" - Tubeless
Type: Carbon
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
5/10
Category
Aero
Weight
8.64 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Brakes
Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Shimano

105

2 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels
Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
6/10
5/10
Category
Aero
Aero
Weight
8.42 kg
8.64 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Carbon
Brakes

Shimano

105 Di2

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Type: Hydraulic Disc
Groupset

Shimano

105 Di2

2 × 12 Electronic
Gearing: 52/36 · 11-34

Shimano

105

2 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels

Giant

Gavia Course 1

Front: 700" - Tubeless
Rear: 700" - Tubeless
Type: Carbon
Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Rigid

Summary!

These are two sporty aero road bikes that share carbon frames, 700c wheels, hydraulic disc brakes, rigid seatposts, and 2×12 drivetrains, making for a focused comparison between similar platforms. Both bikes aim at high-speed riding and sprinting, so the matchup highlights small but meaningful differences.

The Giant is lighter at 8.42 kg versus the Trek's 8.7 kg, which affects acceleration and climbing feel. Tire widths differ—25c on the Giant and 28c on the Trek—while both accept up to 32c clearance; that wider tire choice gives the Trek a bit more compliance and rolling comfort. The Giant ships with 105 Di2 electronic shifting while the Trek lists 105 mechanical, influencing shift feel and setup.

Choose the Giant if you prioritize a lighter, wind‑cheating package with electronic shifting. Opt for the Trek if you prefer slightly wider tires and the comfort they bring on fast group rides.

The Pro's Closet

Best used Road bike deals

Certified pre-owned · 30-day satisfaction guarantee · Free US shipping

Pre-owned 30-day guarantee
View offers on The Pro's Closet

Popular comparisons

The most viewed comparisons around this bike


Similar bikes

Interesting alternatives to discover

At a glance

Compare key features at a glance

Giant Propel Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8
Avg. Aero

Weight

Avg. Aero : 7.9 kg

Light Heavy
Avg. Aero
8.4 kg
8.6 kg

Riding position

Avg. Aero : Sporty

Comfort Race / Aero
Avg. Aero
Giant Propel Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8

Terrain

Avg. Aero : Smooth roads

Smooth pavement Cobbles / Rough
Avg. Aero
Giant Propel Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8

Climbing ease

Avg. Aero : 15 km/h

Rather hard Very easy
Avg. Aero
13 km/h
12 km/h

Top-end speed

Avg. Aero : 58 km/h

Limited Very fast
Avg. Aero
59 km/h
57 km/h

Support Independent Cycling Expertise

Help us remain a free and unbiased service. By sharing with your network, you help thousands of cyclists.

Thank you for your support!