Black Friday:the best bike deals
Home All bikes Bike comparison : Defy Advanced 3 (Triple) Giant 2011 vs Speedster Gravel 40 EQ Scott 2024
Advertisement

Compare the Best Bikes

Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.

PRICE
OPTISCORE
CATEGORY
WEIGHT
TYPE
BRAKES
GROUPSET
WHEELS
FRAME
POWER METER
SEATPOST
Price
OptiScore
5.6/10
Category
Endurance
Weight
TYPE
Carbon
Brakes

Tektro

TK-R540

Type: Rim Brakes
Groupset

Shimano

105

2 × 10 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 12-25
Wheels

Giant

P-R3

Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
4.4/10
Category
Gravel
Weight
11.2 kg
TYPE
Aluminum
Brakes

Shimano

BR-RS305

Type: Mechanical Disc
Groupset

Shimano

Tiagra

2 × 10 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels

Schwalbe

G-One Bite

Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

SCOTT

Speedster Gravel Disc

Type: Aluminum
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
5.6/10
4.4/10
Category
Endurance
Gravel
Weight
11.2 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Aluminum
Brakes

Tektro

TK-R540

Type: Rim Brakes

Shimano

BR-RS305

Type: Mechanical Disc
Groupset

Shimano

105

2 × 10 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 12-25

Shimano

Tiagra

2 × 10 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels

Giant

P-R3

Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum

Schwalbe

G-One Bite

Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminum
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon

SCOTT

Speedster Gravel Disc

Type: Aluminum
Power Meter
None
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Rigid

Summary!

Comparing these two endurance road bikes highlights shared priorities for long rides: both use 700 wheels and aim at comfort and stability for extended efforts. That shared foundation makes this a useful head-to-head for riders who care about steady handling and tire choice flexibility.

The most specific contrasts are clear. The Giant uses a carbon fiber frame paired with rim brakes, while the Scott pairs an aluminum frame with mechanical disc brakes. Those differences affect ride feel and braking performance: carbon frame compliance tends toward a smoother vibration profile, whereas mechanical discs change modulation and stopping on varied surfaces.

Choose the Giant if you prioritize a carbon frame’s smoother ride. Opt for the Scott if you prefer the braking characteristics and robustness of mechanical discs on an aluminum frame.


Similar bikes

Interesting alternatives to discover

At a glance

Compare key features at a glance

Giant Defy Advanced 3 (Triple)
Scott Speedster Gravel 40 EQ
Avg. Endurance

Weight

Avg. Endurance : 8.9 kg

Light Heavy
Avg. Endurance
11.2 kg

Riding position

Avg. Endurance : Balanced

Comfort Race / Aero
Avg. Endurance
Scott Speedster Gravel 40 EQ

Terrain

Avg. Endurance : Mixed

Smooth pavement Cobbles / Rough
Avg. Endurance
Giant Defy Advanced 3 (Triple)
Scott Speedster Gravel 40 EQ

Climbing ease

Avg. Endurance : 13 km/h

Rather hard Very easy
Avg. Endurance
17 km/h
12 km/h

Top-end speed

Avg. Endurance : 56 km/h

Limited Very fast
Avg. Endurance
52 km/h
57 km/h

Support Independent Cycling Expertise

Help us remain a free and unbiased service. By sharing with your network, you help thousands of cyclists.

Thank you for your support!