Compare the Best Bikes
Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.
Shimano
BR-R7170
Shimano
105
Shimano
105 Di2
Rear: 700"
Schwalbe
ONE Fold
Rear: 700" - Tube
Cervélo
Scott
Addict HMF Carbon
Summary!
This head-to-head looks at two carbon endurance road bikes with the same tire width, wheel size and hydraulic disc brakes. Both ride in a moderate position with rigid seatposts and 2×12 gearing, making them comparable choices for long days in the saddle.
The central difference is the groupset: the Caledonia carries mechanical 105 while the Addict has 105 Di2 electronic shifting. That changes the feel and interaction on climbs, surges and long rides—electronic shifting typically gives crisper, fingertip shifts while mechanical shifting relies on cable actuation.
Choose the Caledonia if you prefer a traditional mechanical setup with familiar maintenance. Pick the Addict if you want the switching behavior and control associated with electronic shifting.