Compare the Best Bikes
Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.
RockShox
Yari RC
FOX
36 Float Rhythm Air Grip 3 3-Modes
RockShox
Deluxe Select+
FOX
Float EVOL Performace Trunnion
Shimano
BR-MT520
Shimano
MT520
Shimano
SLX
Sram
X1, SX Eagle
Maxxis
Assegai
Rear: 29" - Tubeless
Maxxis
Dissector
Rear: 29" - Tubeless Ready
Giant
Scott
Genius
Summary!
These two trail MTBs share a 1×12 drivetrain, 29" wheels, hydraulic disc brakes and dropper seatposts, making them natural rivals for all-mountain and trail riding. Both use proven suspension platforms and single-ring gearing for simplified shifting on technical terrain.
The Giant has longer fork travel at 170mm versus 150mm on the Scott, while the Scott carries 150mm rear travel compared with the Giant's 146mm. Scott's carbon frame and lower weight (14.5 kg) contrast with Giant's aluminum frame and 15.38 kg, and the two use different suspension brands: RockShox on the Giant and FOX on the Scott. Tire widths are close, 2.5" on the Giant and 2.6" on the Scott.
Choose the Giant if you prioritize a longer fork stroke and a burly aluminum setup. Opt for the Scott if you want a lighter carbon frame with slightly more rear travel and FOX suspension.