Black Friday:the best bike deals
Home All Bikes Bike Comparison : Defy Advanced 1 Giant 2025 vs Madone SL 5 Gen 8 Trek 2027
Advertisement

Compare the Best Bikes

Side-by-side comparison of all features to choose the best affordable bike.

PRICE
OPTISCORE
CATEGORY
WEIGHT
TYPE
BRAKES
DRIVETRAIN
WHEELS
FRAME
POWER METER
SEATPOST
Price
OptiScore
8.2/10
Category
Endurance
Weight
8.67 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Brakes

Shimano

105 Di2

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Drivetrain

Shimano

105 Di2

2 × 12 Electronic
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-36
Wheels

Giant

Gavia Fondo 1

Front: 700" - Tubeless
Rear: 700" - Tubeless
Type: Aluminium
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
5/10
Category
Aero
Weight
8.64 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Brakes
Type: Hydraulic Disc
Drivetrain

Shimano

105

2 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels
Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminium
Frame

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Price
OptiScore
8.2/10
5/10
Category
Endurance
Aero
Weight
8.67 kg
8.64 kg
TYPE
Carbon
Carbon
Brakes

Shimano

105 Di2

Type: Hydraulic Disc
Type: Hydraulic Disc
Drivetrain

Shimano

105 Di2

2 × 12 Electronic
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-36

Shimano

105

2 × 12 Mechanical
Gearing: 50/34 · 11-34
Wheels

Giant

Gavia Fondo 1

Front: 700" - Tubeless
Rear: 700" - Tubeless
Type: Aluminium
Front: 700"
Rear: 700"
Type: Aluminium
Frame

Giant

Type: Carbon

Trek

Type: Carbon
Power Meter
None
None
Seatpost
Rigid
Rigid

Summary!

Giant Defy Advanced 1 or Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8? Both carbon road bikes use Shimano 105 with 2×12 gearing, 700c wheels, hydraulic disc brakes and a rigid seatpost, and they weigh almost the same at 8.67 kg and 8.7 kg. The difference is in purpose: the Defy is an endurance road bike, the Madone an aero race bike.

The Defy uses electronic 105 Di2 shifting, while the Madone runs mechanical 105. The moderate position of the Defy and its 32c tires, with room for 38c, favor all-day comfort on rough roads. The Madone puts you in a sporty position on 28c tires, with 32c of clearance, for speed on smooth tarmac.

Which one to choose? Choose the Defy Advanced 1 for long rides, sportives and mixed road surfaces. Pick the Madone SL 5 Gen 8 if speed and a racier position matter most.


Popular comparisons

The most viewed comparisons around this bike


Similar bikes

Interesting alternatives to discover

At a glance

Compare key features at a glance

Giant Defy Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8
Avg. endurance

Weight

Avg. endurance : 8.9 kg

Light Heavy
Avg. endurance
8.7 kg
8.6 kg

Riding position

Avg. endurance : Balanced

Comfort Race / Aero
Avg. endurance
Giant Defy Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8

Terrain

Avg. endurance : Mixed

Smooth pavement Cobbles / Rough
Avg. endurance
Giant Defy Advanced 1
Trek Madone SL 5 Gen 8

Climbing ease

Avg. endurance : 13 km/h

Rather hard Very easy
Avg. endurance
12 km/h
12 km/h

Top-end speed

Avg. endurance : 56 km/h

Limited Very fast
Avg. endurance
57 km/h
57 km/h

Support independent cycling expertise

Help us remain a free and impartial service.

Thank you for your support!