Black Friday:the best bike deals

How we test bikes at OptiCycles

Buying a bike, new or used, can quickly become a headache. We get it, which is why OptiCycles wants to make the whole process easier: helping you pay the right price for the bike you want, or decide which bike to buy.
That decision is where our test team comes in. Our testers ride the latest bikes, so they're well placed to compare models and point you to the right bike for you.
Here's a brief overview of how we test bikes and report on what really matters to you.

What we do

When you think of OptiCycles reviews, you probably think of our bike pages: from road bikes to electric cargo bikes, each with full specs, geometry, prices from our retailers and our verdict.

We can't ride every bike and every version of it. That's why each page also draws on an analysis of its components, motor, battery and weight, compared with every bike built for the same kind of riding. Our goal: make it impossible to buy a bike without being able to find out what OptiCycles thinks of it.

Why you can trust OptiCycles reviews

We go over every bike we test with a fine-tooth comb, to see where the brand got it right and where it could do better.

We typically spend at least a week with each bike: enough time to judge comfort on different surfaces (cobblestones, gravel paths, rough pavement) and how it rides in town, uphill and downhill. On an e-bike, we record the real-world range.

But we go further than the ride. We try the display and assist controls to see how easy they are to live with, check how easy the battery is to remove and charge, and judge the build quality.

We also check what matters day to day: carrying the bike up stairs, getting it on a train, fitting a child seat or panniers, and adjusting the fit to your size.

We compare weight and kit with the bikes you might also be considering. One of the many things we've learned: a bigger number doesn't always make a better bike.

Our goal: tell you everything you need to know about living with a bike, in words everyone understands.

How we rate bikes

On the site, you've probably noticed our OptiScore. It's a quick and easy way to see what we think of a bike, and a good starting point.

Every bike gets a score out of 10. It weighs what matters for the way the bike will be ridden: on an electric city bike, the battery and motor count for half; on a race bike, the groupset and weight; on an enduro mountain bike, the suspension and brakes. Each bike is compared with other bikes built for the same use.

Price isn't part of the score: a bike can earn 9 out of 10 and cost far more than its rivals. For value for money, every bike page shows the best cheaper alternatives.

In short, the score brings a bike's strengths and weaknesses together in a single number, so you can compare models before diving into the details.

To help you read the score, here are four pointers: avoid, consider, shortlist and buy. Avoid: you're better off looking elsewhere. Consider: worth a look, but other bikes do better for the same use. Shortlist: one of the best in its category, put it near the top of your list.

Buy? The bike is among the 10% best-equipped in its category: go for it.

How does this relate to the OptiScore? Generally speaking, a bike scoring below 5 should be avoided, 5 to 6.9 is worth considering, 7 to 8.7 should be shortlisted (7 is the average bike in its category), and 8.8 or above is a buy.

How we keep up to date

Bikes change often: a new model year, new colors, sometimes a new motor or a bigger battery. Each model year has its own page, with its own specs and score.

We retest a bike whenever the change is worth checking. A bigger battery promising more range, for example, is worth riding: to find out its real-world range, and whether it's worth paying extra for.

If a bike hasn't changed in a while, we test it again too, to check our verdict still holds up against newer models.

Prices move too, especially during sales and Black Friday. We track them at our retailers, and every price comparison shows when it was last updated.

Where to find us on social media

As well as the website, you can find OptiCycles on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook and Strava.